Can't wait to see your cooks with this! I would consider one if the price is right. We have the regular KBBQ setup with the propane burner and KBBQ topper. I wonder if doing it on the grill with this insert would add much of a grill taste to it? Even though there are slots probably not that much drippings would fall on to the coals, thus not that much smoke from drippings? And assuming cooking while uncovered so not much smoke from coals in general? I'm a noob so forgive any ignorant questions. Sounds like a good experiment for the Weber Test Kitchen though!