The new table fits fine. The way the customer service person sounded, it seemed like it's deeper in the notes than they expect "That won't fit on the older grills...Oh, it looks like I'm reading here that it actually DOES fit." I don't think the customer service reps are used to swapping parts like that so those who say it does not are just assuming because typically they won't.
However, the lid bail does NOT fit and I couldn't get them to send it to me. The table fit great!