Cedar Plank Salmon question?

[addicted-to-smoke]

Welcome to WKC, @northernQ !

That recipe and method sounds interesting. I like the simple ingredients. And I like that it creates a piece of smoke wood for later use. Now to see if I can find some maple planks.

[northernQ]

I'm in Canada so maple and cedar planks are available in several retail grocery stores for about $3 each. You do need to trim the salmon filet to fit.

Try a grocery chain called Sobey's. They may ship to you.   Good luck.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app

[MacEggs]

Welcome, @northernQ !  Where are you located?  I'm in central Ontario.

Great advice trying a maple plank.  I have a few small pieces of sugar maple planks from a tree my Dad and I felled many years ago.
He ended up getting boards cut from the trunk and I have made a cutting board from it.  Damn hard wood, I say.

I want to try that recipe you posted.  Thanks!

[northernQ]

Enjoy! I'm in the Toronto area, and get my maple planks at Sobeys.

Couple of points: if you place the board direct on the coals, the board will warp quickly. Take care that the edges of the salmon don't burn, and use a couple of tongs or long spatulas to lift from both ends. Learned the hard way how easy it is to dump the salmon into the fire. And the board will either be smoking hot or on fire, so have a non flammable surface like a baking sheet to put it on.

If you like your fish less well done, and are concerned about overcooking it, (or are distracted by company and a nice Pinot Noir) put it on the plank on the grill. You won't get the same carmelization but still get a great taste and a slightly more luscious fish. I soak the board 39 minutes of on the grill, and two hours if direct on the coals.

PS Seacore in Woodbridge sells 1 litre containers of Old Bay for about $13, and of course has great fish.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app

[MacEggs]

Thanks for the advice.  The maple planks I have are a little more than an inch thick, so they may not warp as much. 

I rarely get south of Hwy 9, unless I absolutely have to … I'll grab some Old Bay from Costco.

[addicted-to-smoke]

Hmm. Well, needing a long soak for the plank seems like an important detail!

The common denominator I'm seeing here is high heat/short cook time. So with that I have a question. How about I skip the long plank soak, and place it right on top of the grate with coals piled high right under that?

I'd wager it would be even hotter than literally on the charcoal, since charcoal isn't a good conductor of heat (it's why people can quickly walk on coals, but a little bit above that heat is actually hotter.)

[MacEggs]

Hmm. Well, needing a long soak for the plank seems like an important detail!

The common denominator I'm seeing here is high heat/short cook time. So with that I have a question. How about I skip the long plank soak, and place it right on top of the grate with coals piled high right under that?

I'd wager it would be even hotter than literally on the charcoal, since charcoal isn't a good conductor of heat (it's why people can quickly walk on coals, but a little bit above that heat is actually hotter.)

Excellent question / point ATS.  I used to think that soaking the plank was vital … Not so much anymore.

Last time I did cedar planked fish (can't remember if it was salmon), I did NOT soak the plank.  Pretty much got the same results.
And, yes, I placed it on the cooking grate with a basket full of lit charcoal directly underneath.
I am very curious about trying this with a maple plank not soaked.  Worth a try …

After all, instructions say to soak wood chips / chunks for smoking …. How many of us do this, now?  I'm guessing not many.  I sure don't. 

[addicted-to-smoke]

I never soak smoke wood. All that gets me is steam, followed by weak smoke.

All I need is fine, blue smoke for the first part of the cook, and the flavor will be there. I certainly don't need smoking to occur throughout the journey!

[kettlebb]

I never soak smoke wood. All that gets me is steam, followed by weak smoke.

All I need is fine, blue smoke for the first part of the cook, and the flavor will be there. I certainly don't need smoking to occur throughout the journey!

This. Soaking causes smoldering and bad white smoke. When it goes on dry you’ll see thin blue and I also do it early on in the cook and when it’s all burnt up I usually don’t add more. I’ve found if the smoke flavor is subtle you get the protein and rub flavors more than just pure smoke flavor. I don’t cook much fish but I’d like to try planking it sometime.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app

[addicted-to-smoke]

Planking adds a degree of practicality, in that you cook and can also serve on it (on a plate, if the plate's big enough.) I suspect that many of us also like it because it eliminates the fear of fish sticking to the grate and possibly shredding.

The last issue isn't much of a problem with a well-greased grate (or buttered fish ...) and IF you don't try to flip the fish too early. Just like with chicken. Most of my fish cooks are without planking or pans, actually. But I'm starting to lean back to planking and pans. I think you have more opportunity to keep spices and whatnot "engaged" with the fish.

[MacEggs]

@northernQ , I was at Sobey's today and saw the maple planks for $3 as you stated.

https://www.sobeys.com/en/hero_products/compliments-grilling-planks/


They measure 35.6cm X 14cm, which translates to 14" X 5.5".  They appeared to be about a 1/4" to 3/8" thick or so.
I didn't have a tape on me, but it was what most store-bought planks measure in thickness.

[HoosierKettle]

cedar is not a smoke wood nor are any conifer.  That's where turpentine comes from.  Short cooks on a cedar plank I assume are okay, BUT I haven't seen any benefit of using a cedar plank other than presentation.  Any suitable smoke wood will give the intended flavor and their are other choices to aid in keeping the fish together.  I cook whole skin on filets with skin side down over direct heat with apple wood as smoke.  The skin crisps up and you can carefully use a spatula and transfer the entire filet to a cutting board skin and all.  I think cedar plank makes for a nice presentation but I'll pass.  Especially for what they cost.  If I were to use a plank, I would go to the hardware store and buy a cedar board.  They are not treated.

[northernQ]

Seacore is at Hwy 400 about 1km southbof hwy on west side of Leslie. Sobeys has the maple planks about 1/4 thick. I was thinking of grabbing some thicker boards from the local wood shop. Enjoy!!


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app

[addicted-to-smoke]

cedar is not a smoke wood nor are any conifer.  That's where turpentine comes from.  Short cooks on a cedar plank I assume are okay, BUT I haven't seen any benefit of using a cedar plank other than presentation.  Any suitable smoke wood will give the intended flavor and their are other choices to aid in keeping the fish together.  I cook whole skin on filets with skin side down over direct heat with apple wood as smoke.  The skin crisps up and you can carefully use a spatula and transfer the entire filet to a cutting board skin and all.  I think cedar plank makes for a nice presentation but I'll pass.  Especially for what they cost.  If I were to use a plank, I would go to the hardware store and buy a cedar board.  They are not treated.

Yes, but ...

Fish does cook quickly, and the cedar allows "a little something" to be imparted to the fish that's specifically not smoke (nor turpentine?)

The later mention of reusing a plank as smoke wood was in reference to the maple suggestion, since it's a deciduous species.