I haven't seen a thread on this topic and I think it's an under rated one. I've always been one to make my own rubs, primarily the texas style salt and coarse pepper base with a few peripheries like granulated garlic, onion, paprika, cumin, cayenne etc.
As far a supermarket rubs go, I've never been impressed. A lot of the offerings from McCormick and even weber (hate to say it) aren't that good. One exception I've found is McCormick's Applewood rub, friends and family love it and I always keep some on hand when I'm feeling lazy.
So what are you guys using for rubs and where are you getting them?
I'm a total amateur ... I just call it experimentation:
- I really like Sticky Fingers Dry Rub (http://charlestonmag.com/charleston_magazine/recipe/sticky_fingers_dry_bbq_rub). I'll buy a couple paprika jugs and make large amounts of the stuff.
- I was using Alton Brown's Baby-Back (http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/alton-brown/who-loves-ya-baby-back-recipe.html) rub with slight variations, but I have not been using sugar as the primary ingredient for a while. Thinking about getting back on that train again.
- Sometimes just salt and pepper.
- When I combine rubs (often), I usually add some coarse love from Montreal Steak (although I liked the Costco steak seasoning better - discontinued).
- Sometimes I use a local store's (Bradley's Country Store) pork rub, then touch some cayenne and top off with Montreal. Or some Jack Daniels rub, The Shed, etc.
- Most often I find that starting with a fine or sugar based rub, then adding more layers helps improve flavor and complexity. I've had a few instances where a single rub was unimpressive, but combined it shines and is a perfect complement.
Edit: Whoa it's not discontinued! Just not carried locally ... definitely buying a pack. Hasn't been in our Costco for a year!
http://www.costco.com/Kirkland-Signature%E2%84%A2-Steak-Seasoning-4-pack.product.100047638.html
Blieb, thanks for the reply. Sticky fingers definitely looks like it's going to get a try this weekend. It's funny that you mention Alton Brown's rub recipe. It was the first one I tried when I was in high school. My problem with it was the sugar. It seems no matter what the temp you're running it eventually takes on a burnt taste and I've read a lot of articles by experienced chefs who say to stay away from sugar for that reason.
@blieb You in Tallahassee? Figured there ain't too many Bradley Country Stores.
@jdefran yes!
I know
@bwb is also from Tallahassee. I wonder if there are others. Maybe time for a meetup!
I used to be an extreme rub freak. (in more ways than one, giggity)
I was making my own rubs in large quanities back in the early 2000s.
By 2010 I was catering bbq every other weekend or so and my bbq rub had really evolved into something I was proud of.
It was a pain, and it was expensive to make. I started getting a bit lazy and using some well respected commercial rubs. No one really complained. I was mostly using bbq 3000 from Penzey's (which is also pretty expensive)
Then one day I tried all the rubs from Simply Marvelous. Back then it was a small operation. My wife, kids, and myself fell in love with Sweet Seduction by Simply Marvelous.
I did a big catering job for a friends daughters graudation party and I decided to do half and half. 4 butts with my rub, 4 butts with Sweet Seduction.
Hands down, 80% of the people preferred the sweet seduction over my own. I was a bit hurt, but it was a learning for me.
I started using sweet seduction exclusively and my little catering business got to be so busy that I had to stop (for legal reasons)
I still make my own rubs, but they usually start with a high quality commercial rub.
Simply marvelous: sweet seduction, cherry, pecan, peppered cow are all AMAZING
Big Poppa Smokers: Money, Sweet Money - Freaking BITCHIN!!
Oak Ridge BBQ has some magical rubs too
My advice: don't get cocky. try some of of these respected rubs and be prepared to get blown away.
Used Meathead's Memphis Dust for quite a long while but lately I have been using semi local to me commercial rubs called Big Dick's
http://amazingribs.com/recipes/rubs_pastes_marinades_and_brines/meatheads_memphis_dust.html (http://amazingribs.com/recipes/rubs_pastes_marinades_and_brines/meatheads_memphis_dust.html)
http://rubsandmore.com/shop/ (http://rubsandmore.com/shop/)
Quote from: blieb on July 03, 2015, 09:31:07 PM
@jdefran yes!
I know @bwb is also from Tallahassee. I wonder if there are others. Maybe time for a meetup!
That could be fun!
On Rubs - try good old Lowerys on your next pork butt.
Every time I do that people rave!
I usually make my own rubs but for when I'm feeling lazy I keep a stash of Pork Stank from Spices Inc it's great on pork butt or ribs.
http://www.spicesinc.com/p-1131-pork-stank.aspx
Magic Dust for me
http://bbq.about.com/od/rubrecipes/r/bl50617d.htm
Most of the rubs at the store seem to have more heat than my wife likes. There OK for me, but she does not like the heat that pops out. tried making my own, just basic paprika base with sugar, onion and garlic and that worked OK, but I have to make it. Then one of my daughters sent me some, "Tex Joy" and I used it on some baby back ribs and it was good. I recently ordered some Weber honey garlic in the hopes it would be a sweet flavor without heat, but have not tried it yet.
I used this stuff for the first time (forget "trust your butcher", trust
@Winz ) over the 4th, and man is it good on ABTs and chicken. Of course, ABTs have their own built-in heat, but the sweetness of this rub balanced things out nicely. I'll be using it more as the Summer of WKC continues.
(https://c1.staticflickr.com/1/457/19436691511_07163676fd_c.jpg)
I been using the Dizzy Dust Tsunami Rub as one of my main rubs. I like it on chicken and pork but also used on beef.
http://dizzypigbbq.com/portfolio/tsunami-spin/
Thanks for all the feedback, defiantly trying all the recipes and and will look into ordering a few others.
I've fallen in love with Rod Gray's EAT rubs, but I also like Plowboys' Yardbird and Smokin' Guns Hot. But both EAT rubs have a certain character that adds an extra pop. Really killer.
I have tried some commercial rubs but do better making my own. The one exception has been the stuff Dizzy Pig makes. Tried their Cow Lick beef rub and the original Dizzy Dust and really like both.....with the beef rub being somewhat better for what it is. I love that stuff on all beef.
@MrHoss Try out Dizzy's "Swamp Venom" if you can find it......tremendous.....I'd use it all the time if the places I know to carry the brand had that one.....
Quote from: 1buckie on July 12, 2015, 09:09:25 AM
@MrHoss
Try out Dizzy's "Swamp Venom" if you can find it......tremendous.....I'd use it all the time if the places I know to carry the brand had that one.....
@1buckie I love the Dizzy Pig Rubs too! How spicy is the Swamp Venom? There are no stores around me that sell it either so have to order from their website.
Swamp Venom is pretty zingy, but not in a way you'd expect.....that's what I like about their stuff, it's constructed from herbs & spices & not much else & they shy away from the standard burn your face off heat with cayenne, habanero, etc.
Quote from: 1buckie on July 12, 2015, 06:18:52 PM
Swamp Venom is pretty zingy, but not in a way you'd expect.....that's what I like about their stuff, it's constructed from herbs & spices & not much else & they shy away from the standard burn your face off heat with cayenne, habanero, etc.
@1buckie Thank you that is very helpful! I love the heat but my wife...Not so much.
@bbquy You can buffer heat with fine ground turbinado sugar......it comes in sort small pellet form, so if you grind it down a bit it will fit right in & doesn't burn anywhere near as easy as brown sugar....
That's great news! Thank you....you learn something new every day! :D
Made a rack of ribs in Portland on my old 22" (that I gave to my Grandson when he moved to PDX) when my wife and I were babysitting the dog. Bought some "Three Little Pigs" rub at the local Bi-Mart. Cooked at 260F till the rack folded w/ a slight tear from the bone. Not to "hot", best ribs you ever made was her comment. Got to go w/ that for the forseeable future. SJ
Quote from: Troy on July 03, 2015, 09:35:51 PM
I still make my own rubs, but they usually start with a high quality commercial rub.
Simply marvelous: sweet seduction, cherry, pecan, peppered cow are all AMAZING
Big Poppa Smokers: Money, Sweet Money - Freaking BITCHIN!!
Oak Ridge BBQ has some magical rubs too
My advice: don't get cocky. try some of of these respected rubs and be prepared to get blown away.
Agree 100%. There's sooo many good rubs available commercially, that I just stopped messing w/ my own for the most part.
For now I usually use Mad Hunky GP as a base, then use the West Coast Offense rubs mixed in with it. I also really like Rod Gray's EAT BBQ Rubs. Love Tatonka Dust + SM Peppered Cow on beef.
Quote from: THUNDERDOME on July 14, 2015, 10:24:03 AM
. I also really like Rod Gray's EAT BBQ Rubs.
+1
Of all the commercial rubs I have tried, the EAT rubs are my current favorite. Bold, spicy, but not hot. Use "zero to hero" if you like sweet. "The most powerful stuff" is appropriately named and is a great base to start with if you like to tweak and make it your own.
I recently tried their IPO BBQ sauce. I am not normally a vinegar based sauce fan, but it strikes the PERFECT balance between tangy and sweet.
Winz
Has anyone tried the Weber rubs? I've seen the commercials and was curious.
(http://images.tapatalk-cdn.com/15/07/15/49aff40f24d8d6ff6ca96d0c843e9ad5.jpg)
A lot of rubs find their way into my house some good some bad. I like "melt your face off heat" sometimes and other times I want savory and other times I want sweet. I think you can see my point here. Try them all don't get locked in - explore. If you're doing a big cook for a ton of people - yeah you go to your money maker. But for tonight I'm trying out some of Weber's Garlic Sriracha!
Check back in soon - they just went on...
(http://images.tapatalk-cdn.com/15/07/15/d023b0dee1fded42d4df76ef714602df.jpg)
I figured why not - let's see if Weber's Rubs are worth their weight in...salt...
(http://images.tapatalk-cdn.com/15/07/15/26b937bd790355a265be075e328b994e.jpg)
Cheers -
Sent from my HTC One_M8 using Tapatalk
Twas good - heat and flavor but nothing that was over powering.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
@Matt_T Thanks for the feed back. If I try ant of them I'll give my feed back as well.
@bbquy thanks please do. I liked this one and so did my neighbor - he is the benefactor to most of my grilling experiments.
Four thumbs up -
Sent from my HTC One_M8 using Tapatalk