First, I'll tell you what's *not* wrong... Give Bman another star, because he saw this on CL and alerted me in time for me to be first in line! An 'O' code redhead in decent shape and with a newish leg/wheel set, along with a tool holder and a nearly-new Weber chimney for 15 bucks? Ten minutes from my house? Oh, yeah, I'll take that all day long.
(Original owners, and the nicest couple. Retired and moving to Portland, OR, and needing to sell off their much-loved kettle. They were happy to see my excitement, and not too weirded out by my attention to detail re: the age of the kettle, the new lower end, the replacement hinged grate, and the date code stamp. Even when I'm trying to act all casual, the geekery shines through my facade.)
But there's something not right about this, and it took me awhile to figure out what was 'off'. Y'all will prolly figure it out much faster.