If you had to create a this poll to sway your decision, means you are emotionally attached to both.
Personally, I would keep both. IMO, you will regret selling any one of them.
Don't over think it. Unless, you really need to free up some cash ( sell Ranch ) or wife says divorce if not one gone ( sell 26 ), it's not always logical choice. If it was the case, none of us would ever have more than half dozen kettles ever to use and have in possession. You know better than anyone here what your heart is saying. It is telling you to keep both.
I not fortunate enough to own either of them, but if I did- only reason for me to get rid of one would be is if I got nicer Ranch or nicer color 26.