Weber Kettle Club Forums

Grill Talk => Weber Kettle Forum => Topic started by: au4stree on July 26, 2018, 01:04:13 PM

Title: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: au4stree on July 26, 2018, 01:04:13 PM
I didn't see this posted elsewhere, so I thought I'd post.  Thought provoking video...

Also, I noticed they titled this Episode #1, implying there will be other comparison type videos.

https://youtu.be/yDO9EMRgLws

Full disclosure:  I own a SnS Plus (v.1) and a DnG for my performer.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: lksdrinker on July 26, 2018, 01:25:33 PM
I'm trying to choose my words here carefully as I know Dave and ABC is well thought of around these parts.  But all I saw was a poorly done sales pitch that didnt really show too much information.   Yes, it is easier to dump coals into a SNS than it is to set up a snake.  He did prove that for sure and I dont think anyone would dispute it.  But.....thats about all I got out of this.  Sure the snake died out after 12 hours (or did he say 13?), and the SNS went a few hours longer. But, in all honesty how many of us who end up doing 12+ hour cooks would be upset that they'd need to add in more coal once a day!  I'd be tempted to say most of us who would spend 12 hours cooking wouldn't mind the 5 minutes required to set up a snake.....this is low and slow cooking we're aiming for right?  So why the need for speed?

I'm surprised there are zero shots of the interior of either grill once the coals were lit or maybe at the end of the video to show the used up snake and the amount of coal left in the SNS.  I was also surprised that Dave touched on this being physics instead of magic....but didnt bother even briefly explaining the physics behind it?  He mentioned the length of this "cook".....I wonder if there was any food in there being cooked and wonder if there was water placed into the SNS? Also surprised to see its the first version of the SNS since the video is so new. 

I dont want to come off complaining about this as I know it is a product that works as advertised.  But I'm glad I got one with a used kettle as I would be pretty unimpressed if I bought this thing for the real asking price! 
Title: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: HoosierKettle on July 26, 2018, 02:20:03 PM
That was not a convincing video. It would have been much better comparing how they hold temp without the use of an atc.

I would recommend they focus on the two zone convenience and searing action of the sns. (I'm assuming since I don't have one)

The truth is a snake holds perfect temp for hours and produces great results with no temp controller.

Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: au4stree on July 26, 2018, 03:14:59 PM
I think the temperature controllers were used to ensure the best possible comparison.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: addicted-to-smoke on July 26, 2018, 03:23:38 PM
^^^ yes

I have a couple takeaways from the video. I had some mild criticism I shared on his post of this to the Facebook Weber Kettle Fans page. Specifically, I wanted to see Justin (Baby Back Maniac made the video for ABC) count the number of remaining coals after each kettle had been shut down after say, 8 hours.

1) The video topic was "efficiency" which can mean a few different things. Here, it was shown that the same amount of coals lasts longer with an S 'n S for a given temperature in identical kettles. The "same temp" used the assistance of the ATC to eliminate that variable, right?

2) No meat was used, because that's another variable, right?

3) Using differently sized kettles, vent adjustments, meats would all cause the audience to cry "foul." (No pun intended.)

4) The video was obviously not intended to highlight every feature, advantage of the product, or method of using one. Tough crowd here tonight!

*************

The corollary to "longer time" is less fuel used for a given time and temp. Owners of the Summit Charcoal have been telling us this since its inception. Why does that work? Insulation = less heat loss. The video clearly demonstrates that far less heat is getting lost to your backyard with the S 'n S. You can either not believe it, or purchase your own infrared thermometer and run the test yourself, yeah?

The air gap created by the basket is not enough to make the difference. The thicker metal (as compared to Weber baskets) is an additional insulator. The smaller gaps in the connecting walls of an S 'n S means less heat loss before heat reaches the inside kettle walls. That shit adds up.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: kettlebb on July 26, 2018, 03:26:48 PM
My personal and best time with the SnS was just under 10 hours using Stubbs. I did a head to head with a snake and my SnS at home with a brisket cook and my snake ran about 3 hours longer.

The SnS is easy to setup for sure but my experience is the snake runs longer and only costs me my time.

The SnS is a beast of a searing machine and I love that it keeps coals away from my bowl.

Not knocking the product in any way but like most things YMMV. My SnS was a Christmas present. I'm on the fence if I would personally pay full retail for one.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: HoosierKettle on July 26, 2018, 03:37:21 PM

Quote from: addicted-to-smoke on July 26, 2018, 03:23:38 PM
^^^ yes

I have a couple takeaways from the video. I had some mild criticism I shared on his post of this to the Facebook Weber Kettle Fans page. Specifically, I wanted to see Justin (Baby Back Maniac made the video for ABC) count the number of remaining coals after each kettle had been shut down after say, 8 hours.

1) The video topic was "efficiency" which can mean a few different things. Here, it was shown that the same amount of coals lasts longer with an S 'n S for a given temperature in identical kettles. The "same temp" used the assistance of the ATC to eliminate that variable, right?

2) No meat was used, because that's another variable, right?

3) Using differently sized kettles, vent adjustments, meats would all cause the audience to cry "foul." (No pun intended.)

4) The video was obviously not intended to highlight every feature, advantage of the product, or method of using one. Tough crowd here tonight!

*************

The corollary to "longer time" is less fuel used for a given time and temp. Owners of the Summit Charcoal have been telling us this since its inception. Why does that work? Insulation = less heat loss. The video clearly demonstrates that far less heat is getting lost to your backyard with the S 'n S. You can either not believe it, or purchase your own infrared thermometer and run the test yourself, yeah?

The air gap created by the basket is not enough to make the difference. The thicker metal (as compared to Weber baskets) is an additional insulator. The smaller gaps in the connecting walls of an S 'n S means less heat loss before heat reaches the inside kettle walls. That shit adds up.

Wrong. Cooking a similar sized rack of ribs in each one and losing the atc would have still been a better comparison of efficiency and ease of temp control for the 99.9 percent of grillers who don't own or want an atc.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: HoosierKettle on July 26, 2018, 03:38:24 PM
In other words, who cares how efficient it is with a controller.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: kettlebb on July 26, 2018, 03:41:59 PM
Quote from: HoosierKettle on July 26, 2018, 03:38:24 PM
In other words, who cares how efficient it is with a controller.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)


This.

Again in my average joe cook off the snake won.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: addicted-to-smoke on July 26, 2018, 04:41:00 PM
Actually, I care about variables being reduced. Tests with uncontrolled variables are pointless. Uncontrolled variables are not "real world" as much as they are unreliable and suspect to misinterpretation.

Ya'll took science in school, right?
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: HoosierKettle on July 26, 2018, 04:47:38 PM

Quote from: addicted-to-smoke on July 26, 2018, 04:41:00 PM
Actually, I care about variables being reduced. Tests with uncontrolled variables are pointless. Uncontrolled variables are not "real world" as much as they are unreliable and suspect to misinterpretation.

Ya'll took science in school, right?

Yes it was great to gather scientific data for a non practical application.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: addicted-to-smoke on July 26, 2018, 05:11:08 PM
Quote from: HoosierKettle on July 26, 2018, 04:47:38 PM

Quote from: addicted-to-smoke on July 26, 2018, 04:41:00 PM
Actually, I care about variables being reduced. Tests with uncontrolled variables are pointless. Uncontrolled variables are not "real world" as much as they are unreliable and suspect to misinterpretation.

Ya'll took science in school, right?

Yes it was great to gather scientific data for a non practical application.

Holding temps and gauging fuel times is incredibly relevant for what we do. Ignore them, and the methodology used to attain the data, at your peril?

Don't seek a definitive test for each isolated cook, unless you don't care if it translates to the next one.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: kettlebb on July 26, 2018, 05:34:58 PM
There are many more variables out of our control. Ambient temperature, barometric pressure, wind speed and direction and humidity. You know, weather.

Also charcoal variables. Point being there is too much out of our control to gain any relevant data to apply to the next cook.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: addicted-to-smoke on July 26, 2018, 05:44:22 PM
Quote from: kettlebb on July 26, 2018, 05:34:58 PM
There are many more variables out of our control. Ambient temperature, barometric pressure, wind speed and direction and humidity. You know, weather.

Also charcoal variables. Point being there is too much out of our control to gain any relevant data to apply to the next cook.

Can't have 100% certainty, so don't even try to compare? I'm sorry but that's a little too precious, and more importantly, disregards everything that considers decent methodology.

It's fair to say that 2 kettles sitting a foot from each other experience the same ambient temperature, barometric pressure, wind speed and direction and humidity. You know, weather.

It's also reasonable to assert 160 briquets taken from the same Kingsford bag will be very consistent in performance.

Or were we talking about something else, all of a sudden?
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: kettlebb on July 26, 2018, 05:53:36 PM
No sir but you can't apply those burn times to tomorrow, next week, or next season was my point. It's also much different without the ATC in a real cook.

Not trying to one up, in all my SnS long cooks I'm refueling at about the 9 hour mark. I'd like to see what other SnS users say their average burn times are on their cooks.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: addicted-to-smoke on July 26, 2018, 06:23:27 PM
Applying the same numbers to the next time isn't relevant when making a comparison. Applying the same differences between methods to the next time has relevance, because it's the differential that will remain even when variables of weather and meats alter the totals.

For a snake to "last longer" than the S 'n S you'd almost certainly have to be using more charcoal, less air, lower temp, less meat/easier meat, perhaps a S' n S 1.0 instead of a S 'n S 2.0 and so on.

The heat loss alone, through the bowl wall when not using a basket of any sort, is no joke. That lost heat costs extra fuel and air to overcome for a given grate temp, yeah? I honestly did not read where your anecdote accounted for any of those variables.
Title: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: HoosierKettle on July 27, 2018, 07:30:48 AM
I'm not bashing the product at all.  It obviously excels in certain areas.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: Big Dawg on July 27, 2018, 11:31:06 AM
I love it ! ! !  This is starting remind me of all the oil change threads back on the Road Star Clinic forum I used to visit before I got my Indian.

(Synthetic vs Dino . . . 4.5 vs 5 qts . . . popcorn)





BD
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: Transit98 on July 27, 2018, 11:57:21 AM

Quote from: kettlebb on July 26, 2018, 05:53:36 PM
No sir but you can't apply those burn times to tomorrow, next week, or next season was my point. It's also much different without the ATC in a real cook.

Not trying to one up, in all my SnS long cooks I'm refueling at about the 9 hour mark. I'd like to see what other SnS users say their average burn times are on their cooks.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I have had similar refill time around the 9 hour mark. My brothers and I used to cook in 55 drum smokers I made. They would cook 12 hours solid. (I will post pics one of these days)

The key to also remember when cooking slow and low is.................

"If you'r Look'n your not cook'n"

Get the grill up to temp/place meat in position/close lid/ wait 90 minuets before you /take a peek-Spray with apple juice/close that lid and drink. Have faith in the set up!


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: lksdrinker on July 27, 2018, 12:34:45 PM
Quote from: addicted-to-smoke on July 26, 2018, 05:11:08 PM
Quote from: HoosierKettle on July 26, 2018, 04:47:38 PM

Quote from: addicted-to-smoke on July 26, 2018, 04:41:00 PM
Actually, I care about variables being reduced. Tests with uncontrolled variables are pointless. Uncontrolled variables are not "real world" as much as they are unreliable and suspect to misinterpretation.

Ya'll took science in school, right?

Yes it was great to gather scientific data for a non practical application.

Holding temps and gauging fuel times is incredibly relevant for what we do.

holding temp is certainly relevant.  But the use of an ATC surely throws this data right out the window.  You can always hold temps with an ATC if using the SNS  or the snake method.....which the video did a good job showing.  I'm not sure why that might make the SNS a better choice than the snake method though? 

Complete speculation, but the lack of ever opening the lids during this test sort of throws the data askew too.  Sure we try to limit how often we open the lid during a cook.....but I've never made it through a whole cook without peeking at least once or twice.  I wonder if the nature of the "piled" up charcoal in a SNS would cause more of a temp spike if/when opening the lid vs the temp spike that might occur with the snake method if/when you open the lid. 

There comes a point where reducing the variables can make the test look good on paper; but if you cant recreate the same "laboratory setting" at home you'll never get the same results.  Its like how the EPA estimates the gas mileage of a particular car.  Most people/customers will never see the same number in a real world application and if they care to know, they have to compile their own data and do their own real world testing to come up with their own decision.

Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: Schaefd2 on July 27, 2018, 01:49:53 PM
I don't have a SNS but I think if I wanted to cook a long time while maintaining a steady temp, I would definitely use the snake. I've had great results while snaking it up, and I was on pace for a 12 hour run at 250 with 2x2 Royal Oak Ridge.

Isn't the SNS basically using the minion method? If so, I've had terrible results with the minion method. The temp spiked way high (450) because I was laid up with a stomach bug and I couldn't monitor the air vents.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: Foster Dahlet on July 27, 2018, 02:05:19 PM
I like my SnS a lot.  It stays in my grill and I use it for direct, indirect, and low and slow.  It is a versatile accessory and well built.....and it gives me more space when I am doing low and slow.  That said, it is easier for me to dial in the temp on a snake and maintain it at that temp.  The total cook times have been about even for me....but a little longer on the snake.  However, each time I use the SnS for low n slow I get better at dialing in and maintaining temps.....which means less temp spikes and longer cook times.  I think it is a matter of learning and getting one's process down, which leads to better results.   

Sent from my LG-TP260 using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (http://r.tapatalk.com/byo?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: addicted-to-smoke on July 27, 2018, 02:09:51 PM
Quote from: lksdrinker on July 27, 2018, 12:34:45 PM
holding temp is certainly relevant.  But the use of an ATC surely throws this data right out the window.  You can always hold temps with an ATC if using the SNS  or the snake method.....which the video did a good job showing.  I'm not sure why that might make the SNS a better choice than the snake method though? 

Complete speculation, but the lack of ever opening the lids during this test sort of throws the data askew too.  Sure we try to limit how often we open the lid during a cook.....but I've never made it through a whole cook without peeking at least once or twice.  I wonder if the nature of the "piled" up charcoal in a SNS would cause more of a temp spike if/when opening the lid vs the temp spike that might occur with the snake method if/when you open the lid. 

There comes a point where reducing the variables can make the test look good on paper; but if you cant recreate the same "laboratory setting" at home you'll never get the same results.  Its like how the EPA estimates the gas mileage of a particular car.  Most people/customers will never see the same number in a real world application and if they care to know, they have to compile their own data and do their own real world testing to come up with their own decision.

Keep in mind that when car shopping, we are comparing MPG from one vehicle to the others. "That car's relatively efficient. That truck slurps fuel compared to ..." If you realize that it's not a guarantee of on-road MPG, that doesn't change the fact that one vehicle will be relatively more efficient than another, even if the gap between them isn't perfectly, exactly maintained 100% of the time, yeah?

I think it's odd that you're also hung up on this snake vs. SnS test to somehow imply something never claimed, that the charcoal would last "just as long" in your own backyard. That's not the point of a controlled comparison test. At all.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: addicted-to-smoke on July 27, 2018, 02:16:09 PM
Quote from: Schaefd2 on July 27, 2018, 01:49:53 PM
... Isn't the SNS basically using the minion method? If so, I've had terrible results with the minion method. The temp spiked way high (450) because I was laid up with a stomach bug and I couldn't monitor the air vents.


Very similar, sure. I've used ABC's Charcoal Basket (the small one that fits 18s) as a lower-and-slower method, yes by lighting only about 4-6 briquets on one end. And I also saw the temp climb and climb, as the basket became lit but the earliest coals were not yet dead.

But that was on my dancook grill, which only can have the lid vent adjusted. (And my use of Weber cook grate meant the lid probably doesn't perfectly seal.) In short, almost an uncontrolled airleak.

There's that air issue again ... changing the temp variable ...
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: lksdrinker on July 27, 2018, 02:27:36 PM


Quote from: addicted-to-smoke on July 27, 2018, 02:09:51 PM
Quote from: lksdrinker on July 27, 2018, 12:34:45 PM
holding temp is certainly relevant.  But the use of an ATC surely throws this data right out the window.  You can always hold temps with an ATC if using the SNS  or the snake method.....which the video did a good job showing.  I'm not sure why that might make the SNS a better choice than the snake method though? 

Complete speculation, but the lack of ever opening the lids during this test sort of throws the data askew too.  Sure we try to limit how often we open the lid during a cook.....but I've never made it through a whole cook without peeking at least once or twice.  I wonder if the nature of the "piled" up charcoal in a SNS would cause more of a temp spike if/when opening the lid vs the temp spike that might occur with the snake method if/when you open the lid. 

There comes a point where reducing the variables can make the test look good on paper; but if you cant recreate the same "laboratory setting" at home you'll never get the same results.  Its like how the EPA estimates the gas mileage of a particular car.  Most people/customers will never see the same number in a real world application and if they care to know, they have to compile their own data and do their own real world testing to come up with their own decision.

Keep in mind that when car shopping, we are comparing MPG from one vehicle to the others. "That car's relatively efficient. That truck slurps fuel compared to ..." If you realize that it's not a guarantee of on-road MPG, that doesn't change the fact that one vehicle will be relatively more efficient than another, even if the gap between them isn't perfectly, exactly maintained 100% of the time, yeah?

I think it's odd that you're also hung up on this snake vs. SnS test to somehow imply something never claimed, that the charcoal would last "just as long" in your own backyard. That's not the point of a controlled comparison test. At all.

I suppose if fuel economy was your deciding factor in buying a car then yes you would compare like that.  But not everyone does.  Some people want X vehicle (or X anything), and research that thing and all that it does.  Then when they use that thing their results are not always the same. 

I'm not hung up on trying to keep my charcoal that hot for that same amount of time, and  not sure why you'd imply that.   I'm more hung up on the fact that this test basically showed that the SNS does a slightly marginal better job at keeping coals hot vs the snake method.  I personally dont think that slight difference is worth the asking price of the device. 

Like all those gimmicky carburetor or throttle body spacers that promised better fuel efficiency.  They used bogus comparison experiments that showed laboratory results which could never be replicated in real world usage. 

Sent from my SM-G935V using Tapatalk

Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: powermatt99 on July 27, 2018, 02:37:37 PM
Since getting my SNS, I've been using it for all low and slow cooks on my kettle. I light two paraffin cubes, wait for them to burn out and then dial in my temp before adding the delicious animal parts. It was just as easy to maintain temp as a snake and a bit easier to set up. I typically used a smaller snake before the SNS days because I wasn't as deft at dialing in my temps. Less fuel touching meant it was more forgiving with airflow adjustment (or at least that's what my rationale was). It was perfect for ribs but I needed to add fuel for longer cooks.

Bottom line, I found what worked for me with the hardware I had at the time.

I use an ATC now so it doesn't much matter. FWIW, the ATC gave me a lot longer burn times with the same snake setup than without the ATC. That is a function of the efficiency of an ATC.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: addicted-to-smoke on July 27, 2018, 03:12:59 PM
" ... this test basically showed that the SNS does a slightly marginal better job at keeping coals hot vs the snake method.  I personally dont think that slight difference is worth the asking price of the device."

lksdrinker, please understand that I would NEVER (at least I don't intend to?) make value judgements for others. I appreciate you sharing what's important to you, and that you don't think the advantages (assuming they are in fact real) are worth the expense. It not only "makes sense," but is inherently irrefutable. No one can ever dictate to us what something is worth.

P.S. approx 13.5 hrs vs approx 16.5 hrs is approx an 18% difference. Not chicken feed, whether you're talking gasoline or charcoal. :)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: addicted-to-smoke on July 27, 2018, 03:20:27 PM
Quote from: powermatt99 on July 27, 2018, 02:37:37 PM
Since getting my SNS, I've been using it for all low and slow cooks on my kettle. I light two paraffin cubes, wait for them to burn out and then dial in my temp before adding the delicious animal parts. It was just as easy to maintain temp as a snake and a bit easier to set up. I typically used a smaller snake before the SNS days because I wasn't as deft at dialing in my temps. Less fuel touching meant it was more forgiving with airflow adjustment (or at least that's what my rationale was). It was perfect for ribs but I needed to add fuel for longer cooks.

Bottom line, I found what worked for me with the hardware I had at the time.

I use an ATC now so it doesn't much matter. FWIW, the ATC gave me a lot longer burn times with the same snake setup than without the ATC. That is a function of the efficiency of an ATC.

My snakes take (in my view) "a long time" to settle in. Too cold, then maybe too hot, now fix the temp again and so on. Not a problem if you account for that.

@ powermatt99 I'm still green with my regular 1.0 S'nS (has no bottom) but have already noticed the bowl doesn't run as hot compared to a Weber or homemade basket ... my question is, you're loading up the basket, lighting 2 cubes, then after they're dead close everything down a bit?

I think we're all searching for reliable, repeatable setups here, with either smoking or with grilling.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: KettleMaster on July 27, 2018, 09:16:48 PM
Obviously a great product but you cant deny the video was a pretty biased sales pitch imho.I have used the Snake for Pulled Pork,Brisket,Ribs and other long cooks and had no issues.It only takes around 5 mins to build a 2×2 snake which is no big deal if you are doing a long cook lol

Sent from my SM-G930W8 using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (http://r.tapatalk.com/byo?rid=91018)

Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: MacEggs on July 28, 2018, 07:34:45 AM

I didn't bother watching the video ...

http://weberkettleclub.com/forums/grilling-bbqing/fuse-snake-lasted-11-plus-hours/

http://weberkettleclub.com/forums/grilling-bbqing/the-18'-outrider-is-a-great-cooker/
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: powermatt99 on July 28, 2018, 02:13:09 PM
Quote from: addicted-to-smoke on July 27, 2018, 03:20:27 PM
Quote from: powermatt99 on July 27, 2018, 02:37:37 PM
Since getting my SNS, I've been using it for all low and slow cooks on my kettle. I light two paraffin cubes, wait for them to burn out and then dial in my temp before adding the delicious animal parts. It was just as easy to maintain temp as a snake and a bit easier to set up. I typically used a smaller snake before the SNS days because I wasn't as deft at dialing in my temps. Less fuel touching meant it was more forgiving with airflow adjustment (or at least that's what my rationale was). It was perfect for ribs but I needed to add fuel for longer cooks.

Bottom line, I found what worked for me with the hardware I had at the time.

I use an ATC now so it doesn't much matter. FWIW, the ATC gave me a lot longer burn times with the same snake setup than without the ATC. That is a function of the efficiency of an ATC.
@ powermatt99 I'm still green with my regular 1.0 S'nS (has no bottom) but have already noticed the bowl doesn't run as hot compared to a Weber or homemade basket ... my question is, you're loading up the basket, lighting 2 cubes, then after they're dead close everything down a bit?

I think we're all searching for reliable, repeatable setups here, with either smoking or with grilling.

Exactly. SNS 1.0 here too. Even with an ATC, I keep everything open until the cubes are spent. After that cover and close down vents to dial in, or cover and activate ATC. Though not entirely necessary, the beauty of the ATC is that I can do other things besides crush beers while BBQing.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: Troy on July 28, 2018, 02:16:18 PM
sigh

i've been wanting to make this video for more than a year. when I saw they published it I was relieved, now I don't need to make the video afterall!

After watching it, I think I still need to make the video. :\
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: HoosierKettle on July 28, 2018, 02:43:25 PM

Quote from: Troy on July 28, 2018, 02:16:18 PM
sigh

i've been wanting to make this video for more than a year. when I saw they published it I was relieved, now I don't need to make the video afterall!

After watching it, I think I still need to make the video. :\

Yes for sure. I would like to see what you come up with.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: TD on July 28, 2018, 04:16:17 PM
It don't take long to fill the lid of a Weber with hot gasses from a bed of lit briquettes. A single Weber basket of lit briquettes is enough to hit smoking temps in my neighborhood. I start a batch of coals in a second kettle and let them ash over and then shut the vents down. I only do this to keep from adding raw KBB to the cook so don't care if they go out prior to adding them. Ash tends to build up in the basket over time and tends to slow the heat, so when the lid comes off I stir to coals gently clearing the ash into the lower kettle where the one touch can manage. I also check the meat and add the ashed over briquettes and wood chunks as needed using tongs. I enjoy looking. Don't mind checking a long cook every 1 to 2 hours. My temperature graphs wouldn't be as linear but seems cook good enough for me. George's kettle is one bad a** cooking machine and covers my looking and not cooking.
   
   Without the ATC I wouldn't expect the SNS temps to be as linear as a snake. A full SNS pretty much has to use the minion set up.
   
    If you don't want the snake to run under the meat you will need to rotate the cooking grate for a long brisket or ribs, and then what about a drip pan? For a Pork butt or a half brisket or short racks of ribs with the drip pan in the center I don't see how you can beat a snake for a set and forget cook in the kettle.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: KettleMaster on July 28, 2018, 10:19:07 PM
Im on Team Snake! Served me well & it doesnt take much to set up...unless you have no hands LOL

Sent from my SM-G930W8 using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (http://r.tapatalk.com/byo?rid=91018)

Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: ABCbarbecue on July 29, 2018, 07:42:58 AM
Sheesh tough room.  Here are some comments.

1) When I said "physics not magic" it was after demonstrating the exterior walls of the kettle are cooler with the SnS, thus more heat is retained in the cooker, which means more efficiency.  I admit I could have gone into that detail but we were trying to keep the video short.

2) ATC invalidates the test?  This is TOTAL HOGWASH.  I don't even say hogwash... not sure where that came from.  The ATCs guaranteed each kettle was at the same temp the entire cook....  This was an efficiency test... not how easy is it to control temp test. 

3) Should have opened the lid?  If we had opened the lid as needed based on the type of cook then the SnS would have been even farther ahead, because you don't need to open the lid.  With the Snake you're either confined to a small indirect zone or you have to rotate the meat away from the heat as it cooks.

4) Should have used meat?  Bad idea...  There is no way to guarantee two pieces of meat are identical, and the meat would have added no value to an efficiency comparison.

5) I would also point out it was a very hot day/evening....  It was in the high 90s for most of the period the snake was going... about the time it went out the ambient temp had died down to mid 70s, yet the SnS still went another 3+ hours.  On a cooler day the difference would have been even more dramatic.

6) This was a sales pitch?  Of course it was!  HOWEVER, we pitched scientific data, not marketing spin.  And we made the comparison FAIR/FAVORING the snake method.

7) Why didn't they show the kettles after the cook?  There was nothing left but ash.  Kinda boring.

@troymeister would be interested to know what you feel the test is missing.
Title: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: HoosierKettle on July 29, 2018, 08:04:06 AM
I can see how the test was scientific and fair, but  I'm  not sure it's applicable without controller.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: ABCbarbecue on July 29, 2018, 08:10:58 AM
Quote from: HoosierKettle on July 29, 2018, 08:04:06 AM
I can see how the test was scientific, I'm  not sure it's applicable without controller.

Of course it's applicable.  Both methods allow for easy temperature control.  If we hadn't set the controllers, everyone would be accusing us of running the snake hot. 

Seriously, your argument lacks any merit.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: kettlebb on July 29, 2018, 09:12:21 AM
I'd agree with HoosierKettle on the comment about the ATC. My results with the SnS have always had temp spikes as the fuel in the middle of the basket gets going and the initial fuel isn't completely dead yet.

The snake has been a more constant temp in my cooks without the temp spikes.

I like my SnS but if I really want steady temps I setup a snake.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: KettleMaster on July 29, 2018, 09:53:41 AM
Snake once set up properly you really cant go wrong with...long steady cooks...im sure the SnS does a pretty good job also i just comes down to preference.

Sent from my SM-G930W8 using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (http://r.tapatalk.com/byo?rid=91018)

Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: troymeister on July 29, 2018, 10:37:05 AM
@ABCbarbecue Hi Dave, always nice to hear from you. I don't think your test is missing anything. I believe it was as fair and scientific as humanly possible. I honestly don't know if anything else could be done to make it fairer.

While both methods clearly work for low and slow cooks, the test shows the SnS is far easier, more efficient and offers much more flexibility in regards to any cook. I personally have found the snake method to be awkward and less reliable way to cook. Often the fuse gets broken somehow and the fire dies. Happened to me a couple of times in the days before the SnS.

For several years now I am all in with the SnS!!

Troymeister
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: cumminfourya on July 29, 2018, 10:56:15 AM
Quote from: ABCbarbecue on July 29, 2018, 07:42:58 AM
Sheesh tough room.  Here are some comments.

1) When I said "physics not magic" it was after demonstrating the exterior walls of the kettle are cooler with the SnS, thus more heat is retained in the cooker, which means more efficiency.  I admit I could have gone into that detail but we were trying to keep the video short.

2) ATC invalidates the test?  This is TOTAL HOGWASH.  I don't even say hogwash... not sure where that came from.  The ATCs guaranteed each kettle was at the same temp the entire cook....  This was an efficiency test... not how easy is it to control temp test. 

3) Should have opened the lid?  If we had opened the lid as needed based on the type of cook then the SnS would have been even farther ahead, because you don't need to open the lid.  With the Snake you're either confined to a small indirect zone or you have to rotate the meat away from the heat as it cooks.

4) Should have used meat?  Bad idea...  There is no way to guarantee two pieces of meat are identical, and the meat would have added no value to an efficiency comparison.

5) I would also point out it was a very hot day/evening....  It was in the high 90s for most of the period the snake was going... about the time it went out the ambient temp had died down to mid 70s, yet the SnS still went another 3+ hours.  On a cooler day the difference would have been even more dramatic.

6) This was a sales pitch?  Of course it was!  HOWEVER, we pitched scientific data, not marketing spin.  And we made the comparison FAIR/FAVORING the snake method.

7) Why didn't they show the kettles after the cook?  There was nothing left but ash.  Kinda boring.

@troymeister would be interested to know what you feel the test is missing.

He said "hogwash"


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: 56MPG on July 29, 2018, 12:30:55 PM
Physicists would want to know whether the snake in the test was running clockwise or counterclockwise, and whether the coals were lit right to left or left to right in the SnS. God forbid you had the snake running counterclockwise and the SnS right to left at the same time. That could cause a space-time rift the likes of which the world has never seen!

I am not a Physicist, although I had a cyst on my fist a while back. I have used snakes running both directions. I have used my own version of a SnS, and wish I had the real deal. (My birthday is coming up a week from Wednesday, hopefully my wife got the hint. Well, more like "get me this exact thing for my birthday!") I love everything about the real deal; well-made, more real estate, higher temps possible for longer periods of time, easier cleanup, etc. Paired with the custom SS grate (I already have the 26er version, but would love a 22.5 too) it's a perfect grilling combo.

I don't think there's a BBQ video out there that this crew has not blown apart with criticism and skepticism. How many of these skeptics have built their own shit, tested it, manufactured it, marketed it, made a business of it and otherwise advanced the hobby? N=0.  I'm not even sure it matters that it be compared to the snake at all. That's like comparing a funny car to a Pike's Peak hill climber. (But for the record the funny car would kick the Pikes Peak car's ass.)

Thanks for making your own shit @ABCbarbecue .

Marty
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: Troy on July 29, 2018, 04:03:39 PM
Quote from: troymeister on July 29, 2018, 10:37:05 AM
@ABCbarbecue Hi Dave, always nice to hear from you. I don't think your test is missing anything. I believe it was as fair and scientific as humanly possible. I honestly don't know if anything else could be done to make it fairer.

While both methods clearly work for low and slow cooks, the test shows the SnS is far easier, more efficient and offers much more flexibility in regards to any cook. I personally have found the snake method to be awkward and less reliable way to cook. Often the fuse gets broken somehow and the fire dies. Happened to me a couple of times in the days before the SnS.

For several years now I am all in with the SnS!!

Troymeister


Best first post ever
Title: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: vwengguy on July 30, 2018, 02:34:12 AM
Deleted by poster.

Dave, @ABCbarbecue .. Great Product! Thank You.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: ABCbarbecue on July 30, 2018, 03:02:22 AM
Quote from: troymeister on July 29, 2018, 10:37:05 AM
@ABCbarbecue Hi Dave, always nice to hear from you. I don't think your test is missing anything. I believe it was as fair and scientific as humanly possible. I honestly don't know if anything else could be done to make it fairer.

While both methods clearly work for low and slow cooks, the test shows the SnS is far easier, more efficient and offers much more flexibility in regards to any cook. I personally have found the snake method to be awkward and less reliable way to cook. Often the fuse gets broken somehow and the fire dies. Happened to me a couple of times in the days before the SnS.

For several years now I am all in with the SnS!!

Troymeister

DUDE.  I totally tagged you by accident.  I meant TROY.  What are the chances? LOL Hope things are good with you.  Haven't seen you in the group much lately. ;)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: ABCbarbecue on July 30, 2018, 03:05:04 AM
Quote from: Troy on July 29, 2018, 04:03:39 PM
Quote from: troymeister on July 29, 2018, 10:37:05 AM
@ABCbarbecue Hi Dave, always nice to hear from you. I don't think your test is missing anything. I believe it was as fair and scientific as humanly possible. I honestly don't know if anything else could be done to make it fairer.

While both methods clearly work for low and slow cooks, the test shows the SnS is far easier, more efficient and offers much more flexibility in regards to any cook. I personally have found the snake method to be awkward and less reliable way to cook. Often the fuse gets broken somehow and the fire dies. Happened to me a couple of times in the days before the SnS.

For several years now I am all in with the SnS!!

Troymeister


Best first post ever

YOU'RE the @Troy I was trying to tag.  Major tag failure.  I agree you should do a vid!  The more the merrier.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: ABCbarbecue on July 30, 2018, 03:07:27 AM
Quote from: kettlebb on July 29, 2018, 09:12:21 AM
I'd agree with HoosierKettle on the comment about the ATC. My results with the SnS have always had temp spikes as the fuel in the middle of the basket gets going and the initial fuel isn't completely dead yet.

The snake has been a more constant temp in my cooks without the temp spikes.

I like my SnS but if I really want steady temps I setup a snake.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

The SnS will hold very steady temps so I think there's two possibilities here.  1) You got leaks around the lid 2) You ran out of water.  Around 5 hours into the cook when the water runs out you'll sometimes see a temp spike, especially if you're not cooking a huge hunk of meat that's stalling and replacing the moisture that was coming from the reservoir.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: captjoe06 on July 30, 2018, 05:32:37 AM
I've yet to use my SnS 2.0 although I'm looking forward to doing so.  So busy with work I have it planned for January for a brisket.


I've been a huge fan of the snake method for long cooks.  I've never had one go out on me and find it's been to date absolutely foolproof for maintaining smoking temps I'm comfortable with.


I don't neatly arrange coals for the snake method, i dump a bunch of briquettes in and push them up along the side starting at about 7:30 on the dial and stopping around 3:00.


Without ever using the SNS a benefit I'm expecting is that with the amount of coals it will hold over to the side on a brisket on a 22 I'm guessing there will be zero reason to have to rotate the grate as all the coals will be in the SnS basket to the left and the Brisket will be to the right.


The other benefit I anticipate is protecting the porcelain on my favorite kettles.


It does seem like a luxury item, not a must have.  i'll report back once I've actually used it.


All that being said, after seeing a 26 with a snake method in action at the Northeast Meetup, i think that may be the best grill ever for the money.


Easily can do a packer brisket with a snake and  maintain a really long effortless cook.


After seeing that in action I felt no need to ever think about a pellet pooper or atc.


The 26 with a snake just held temp rock solid all day long.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: HoosierKettle on July 30, 2018, 05:33:21 AM
Almost all of the comments in this thread were a respectful exchange of different opinions. So I don't compare this thread to all of the random hateful rhetoric found in comment sections in other social media.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: Zinn on July 30, 2018, 06:32:54 AM
The top vent setting on the snake method was 2/3 of the way open, the top vent setting on the SnS was maybe 1/4 of the way open. Not a fair head to head comparison.  Of course the snake method was gonna burn out quicker, come on Dave.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: ABCbarbecue on July 30, 2018, 06:54:13 AM
Quote from: Zinn on July 30, 2018, 06:32:54 AM
The top vent setting on the snake method was 2/3 of the way open, the top vent setting on the SnS was maybe 1/4 of the way open. Not a fair head to head comparison.  Of course the snake method was gonna burn out quicker, come on Dave.

The top vents were adjusted as needed so the cookers would maintain 225 F.  Snake method requires more air because it's less efficient...  So it makes perfect sense the top vent would end up more open.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: kettlebb on July 30, 2018, 07:11:18 AM
@Troy will you do your own video of this experiment and if so will you do it without the use of an ATC?
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: vwengguy on July 30, 2018, 07:20:10 AM

Quote from: HoosierKettle on July 30, 2018, 05:33:21 AM
Almost all of the comments in this thread were a respectful exchange of different opinions. So I don't compare this thread to all of the random hateful rhetoric found in comment sections in other social media.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)

Ok.. To everyone that has endured the pain of my rant and rave post... sorry!

I will shut the fuck up and keep my opinions to my self.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: HoosierKettle on July 30, 2018, 07:54:05 AM

Quote from: vwengguy on July 30, 2018, 07:20:10 AM

Quote from: HoosierKettle on July 30, 2018, 05:33:21 AM
Almost all of the comments in this thread were a respectful exchange of different opinions. So I don't compare this thread to all of the random hateful rhetoric found in comment sections in other social media.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)

Ok.. To everyone that has endured the pain of my rant and rave post... sorry!

I will shut the fuck up and keep my opinions to my self.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)

Don't sweat it. You're one of my favorite people on here. Always good advice. And even though it was respectable bashing it was a little bashing none the less. So I apologize for that to ABC


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: KettleMaster on July 30, 2018, 11:09:43 AM
Good back and forth on this subject...Dave from ABC has good answers for ppl who question his testing.I would like to see someone do a Snake video in favour of it and let the fun debates continue;)

Sent from my SM-G930W8 using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (http://r.tapatalk.com/byo?rid=91018)

Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: Twangin on July 30, 2018, 04:43:09 PM
So to add to this I'm curious to know how the slow n sear compares to just using a plain ol' Weber charcoal basket on one side/water pan on other side (underneath meat) for use as a two zone setup for searing or low & slow cooks. Quite a huge price difference between the two, especially for someone like me just getting into the charcoal grill world.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: HoosierKettle on July 31, 2018, 02:51:32 AM
Quote from: Twangin on July 30, 2018, 04:43:09 PM
So to add to this I'm curious to know how the slow n sear compares to just using a plain ol' Weber charcoal basket on one side/water pan on other side (underneath meat) for use as a two zone setup for searing or low & slow cooks. Quite a huge price difference between the two, especially for someone like me just getting into the charcoal grill world.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Forget the basket. It's too small in comparison.  Just dump a full chimney on one side and cook on the other as an alternative.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: captjoe06 on July 31, 2018, 03:43:58 AM
Quote from: HoosierKettle on July 31, 2018, 02:51:32 AM
Quote from: Twangin on July 30, 2018, 04:43:09 PM
So to add to this I'm curious to know how the slow n sear compares to just using a plain ol' Weber charcoal basket on one side/water pan on other side (underneath meat) for use as a two zone setup for searing or low & slow cooks. Quite a huge price difference between the two, especially for someone like me just getting into the charcoal grill world.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Forget the basket. It's too small in comparison.  Just dump a full chimney on one side and cook on the other as an alternative.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)


You could also use firebricks to separate the coals on one side.
Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: Foster Dahlet on July 31, 2018, 07:34:51 AM
Quote from: captjoe06 on July 31, 2018, 03:43:58 AM
Quote from: HoosierKettle on July 31, 2018, 02:51:32 AM
Quote from: Twangin on July 30, 2018, 04:43:09 PM
So to add to this I'm curious to know how the slow n sear compares to just using a plain ol' Weber charcoal basket on one side/water pan on other side (underneath meat) for use as a two zone setup for searing or low & slow cooks. Quite a huge price difference between the two, especially for someone like me just getting into the charcoal grill world.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Forget the basket. It's too small in comparison.  Just dump a full chimney on one side and cook on the other as an alternative.


Sent from my iPhone using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (https://siteowners.tapatalk.com/byo/displayAndDownloadByoApp?rid=91018)


You could also use firebricks to separate the coals on one side.
This is what I did for quite some time, before I learned about snake...then I moved to SnS.  Both are better than firebrick minion method.

Sent from my LG-TP260 using Weber Kettle Club mobile app (http://r.tapatalk.com/byo?rid=91018)

Title: Re: SnS vs. the Snake method
Post by: Twangin on July 31, 2018, 08:24:20 AM
Ok cool, thanks for the info. I'll carry on with just piling straight on the grate to one side until I'm ready to shell out the $ for a slow n sear.. they do look really well made and the design makes sense as to why it works so well.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk