This one has got damage on the rim of the lid. Look at the picture taken from the back of the grill. The enamel has been scraped off down to bare metal. It will be rusting in no time. If you look close, you can see whoever assembled it did a sloppy, careless job. They mounted the two "S" tabs on the back instead of the front where they belong. These tabs are designed to act as a stop for the lid when you're closing it. This is why the lid was damaged no doubt.