Weber Kettle Club Forums

Cooking & Food Talk => Charcoal Grilling & BBQ => Topic started by: Big Dawg on November 11, 2026, 01:27:03 PM

Title: Tale of Two Tenderloins
Post by: Big Dawg on November 11, 2026, 01:27:03 PM
Had family coming into town Sunday.  My sister & B-i-L were on their way to see grandkids in Tampa, so they stop here in St. Augustine to break up the trip.  I decided to grab a couple of pork tenderloins out of the freezer.  But what I found was that 1 of them was actually a turkey breast tenderloin that I guess I bought by mistake.

Well at that point it was go with what ya' got time.

If you've never cooked turkey tenderloins, and I hadn't, there are actually two smaller pieces that come in a package that, deceivingly, looks like a pork tenderloin.

The pork was already lemon-pepper seasoned and I went old school Italian style with the turkey.

Along with the meats I blanched and then grilled some Brussel Sprouts.

Two Tenderloins.jpeg

Finished off with some Farfalle that was sautéed in butter and parsley 'till it got a little crispy . . . a favorite of my family, my sister especially.  Last minute we decided to add some Red Lobster Cheddar Biscuits.

Tenderloins Plated.jpeg

It all turned out good.  Both meats came out juicy and tender.  I did cook the turkey to about 170º, 150º for the pork.  I was a little surprised that the turkey loin did not really have a "turkey" taste to it. It could've been chicken if you didn't read the package.

But everyone enjoyed dinner.  Not sure if I'll purposefully try the turkey again or not.

Title: Re: Tale of Two Tenderloins
Post by: bamakettles on November 12, 2026, 05:31:04 AM
Ah very nice!  Looks like Thanksgiving turkey showed up a little early and in a tasty way.  Nice looking plate of food there that I would be happy to devour!

Cheers!
Title: Re: Tale of Two Tenderloins
Post by: Big Dawg on November 14, 2026, 11:02:56 AM
Yes, I've never actually cooked a full turkey.  My mom always did them and, until she passed, I always had Thanksgiving with the family.

Since she has passed, and I've moved to Florida, I cook for Thanksgiving.

I've got one daughter, and her family, that live down here.  Plus my daughter, and her family, from NC come down for the week.  This is our big family Holiday get together.

Over the years, we've tried a variety of meals, because I thought that none of them really "liked" turkey.  But then one year one of S-i-Ls commented that he did like turkey and wanted me to smoke on.  SO, for the last couple of years I've smoking a bone-in breast and (lately) a Tri-Tip, 'cause they all really love those, too.

Anyway . . . long story-short, if I ever pick up those turkey tenderloins again, I'm thinking a brine might bring out of a turnkey flavor.  Not that they were dry, you can see in the plated picture that they weren't.