So I ended up placing an order through Weber instead of Ereplacements.
Let me tell you that for my order Weber was much cheaper.
That seems to be the trend... I just placed an order through Weber for a couple misc things I needed. Here's how it broke down:
Weber: Parts $41.20, Tax $2.47, Shipping $7.00, Total 50.67
eReplacementParts: Parts $43.95, Tax $0.00, Shipping $12.22, Total 56.17
Both were for ground shipping.